Answers
Chargeback questions,
answered in plain English.
Short, sourced answers to the questions ecom merchants ask about chargebacks: what to do when one lands, why a dispute was lost despite proof of delivery, how many chargebacks are too many, when Shopify can hold payouts, and what Stripe Radar or AI can do. Each answer links to the tool or guide that goes deeper.
- 7-day free trial
- Flat, public pricing
- No percentage of recovered chargebacks
- Security you can check
- Cancel in the app
Winning and losing disputes
Why did I lose a chargeback when I had proof of delivery?
Proof of delivery answers an item-not-received claim, but not every chargeback is one.
AnswerCan you appeal a chargeback you lost?
Usually not on your own. Shopify says there is no appeal once you lose a Shopify Payments chargeback, and Stripe disputes end at the issuer's decision.
AnswerCan a chargeback be reversed?
Yes, if the bank accepts your evidence. You answer through your processor before its deadline with evidence that fits the reason code, and if the cardholder's bank accepts it, the funds are returned.
AnswerWhich chargebacks should you accept rather than fight?
Accept when your own records show the claim is right, such as a declined or duplicated charge, or when the reason code is one that is usually accepted.
AnswerWhat happens if you lose a chargeback?
The disputed amount stays with the cardholder, and the chargeback fee usually stays with your processor.
AnswerWhat happens when you win a chargeback?
The cardholder's bank reverses the chargeback and the disputed amount is returned to you.
AnswerCan a merchant fight a chargeback?
Yes. You answer the chargeback through your payment processor with evidence that fits the reason code, before the processor's deadline, which is usually 7 to 21 days on Stripe and Shopify Payments.
AnswerWho pays for a chargeback?
Usually the merchant. When a chargeback arrives, the disputed amount is debited from you, and your processor charges a fee.
AnswerWhat should you do first when you get a chargeback?
Read the reason code and the due date before anything else, and don't refund the order: the money has already been taken back.
AnswerCan a customer cancel a chargeback after filing it?
Yes. Every card network lets the cardholder withdraw a chargeback by contacting their bank, according to Stripe.
AnswerDoes a customer have to contact you before filing a chargeback?
Not always. Shopify says card networks expect customers to try to resolve a problem with the merchant before disputing, and some reason codes build that in, such as Mastercard 4853.
AnswerCan AI fight chargebacks for you?
AI can do most of the writing: it can draft a response from your store's records that follows the reason code, and check the cardholder's claim against those records.
Refunds and cancellations
Can a customer file a chargeback after I refunded them?
Yes. A cardholder can still dispute a charge after you refunded it, for example as Visa 13.6 Credit Not Processed.
AnswerWhat is the difference between a chargeback and a refund?
A refund is money you choose to send back to the customer.
AnswerCan a customer charge back an order they cancelled?
Yes. A cardholder who cancelled, or says they did, can dispute the charge, for example as Visa 13.7 Cancelled Merchandise/Services or 13.6 Credit Not Processed.
AnswerDoes a no-refund or return policy stop chargebacks?
No. A policy can't stop a cardholder from disputing, and for some reason codes it doesn't decide the case: Visa says the return policy has no bearing on 13.3 not-as-described disputes.
AnswerDoes a customer have to return the item in a chargeback?
It depends on the reason code. For not-as-described (Visa 13.3) and cancelled merchandise (Visa 13.7) disputes, the cardholder generally must have returned or tried to return the goods first.
Deadlines and timing
Chargeback ratio
How many chargebacks are you allowed before you get flagged?
It's a ratio, not a fixed number. Processors and card networks start flagging stores at around 1% of orders disputed.
AnswerCan one chargeback hurt a small store?
It can. At low volume one dispute moves your ratio a lot: one chargeback in 45 orders is about 2.2%, and processors and card networks start flagging stores at around 1% of orders disputed.
AnswerWhat happens if your chargeback ratio is too high?
It escalates in steps. Your processor can hold part of your payouts as a reserve, card network programs such as Visa VAMP and Mastercard ECM add fees and remediation, and persistent problems can end in termination and a MATCH listing.
AnswerWhat is a normal chargeback rate for an ecom store?
There's no official industry average that card networks publish; what they publish are thresholds.
AnswerWhat goes in a chargeback reduction plan?
It's a short written plan, usually asked for by your acquirer or processor once disputes climb.
Reason codes
What does a dispute reason like "fraudulent" or "product not received" mean?
It is your processor's label for the card network's reason code.
AnswerWhat is chargeback reason code 37?
On a Mastercard debit transaction, 37 is the two-digit Single Message System version of reason code 4837, No Cardholder Authorization: the cardholder says they didn't authorize the payment.
AnswerHow do Visa, Mastercard and Amex chargeback rules differ?
The filing windows are similar, mostly 120 days, but the steps differ.
AnswerWhy did I get a "subscription canceled" chargeback when I don't sell subscriptions?
Usually because the bank chose the nearest reason, not because you sell subscriptions.
Fraud and abuse
What does "high risk of fraud" mean on a Shopify order?
It means Shopify's fraud analysis rates the order as having a high risk of a chargeback, based on indicators such as AVS and CVV results, location mismatches and unusual device or network activity.
AnswerWhat is return fraud?
Return fraud usually means returning something other than what was bought, such as an empty box, a swapped item or stolen goods, to get a refund.
AnswerDoes Shopify protect sellers from chargebacks?
Partly. Shopify Protect covers eligible Shop Pay orders against fraudulent and unrecognized chargebacks at no cost.
AnswerWhat does medium risk mean on a Shopify order?
It means Shopify's fraud analysis sees some risk of a chargeback due to fraud, but less than on a high-risk order.
AnswerHow do you answer a fraud chargeback on Shopify?
First check whether Shopify Protect covers it: it protects eligible Shop Pay orders against fraudulent and unrecognized chargebacks.
AnswerWhy would a customer not recognize a charge from my store?
Usually because the name on their statement isn't the store they remember, or someone else in the household placed the order.
AnswerHow do you protect high-value orders from chargebacks?
Check them before they ship and keep the records each claim needs.
AnswerHow do you stop refund abuse and return fraud on Shopify?
Make the rules clear, then check before you refund.
Processors and platforms
Where do you find chargebacks in Shopify?
In Shopify admin, go to Orders, then Search and filter, add the filter Chargeback and inquiry status and choose Open.
AnswerCan chargebacks get your Shopify payouts held?
They can. Shopify can place a reserve on a Shopify Payments account, holding a portion of each transaction, or in some cases the full amount, to cover potential chargebacks and refunds.
AnswerHow do Klarna disputes work for merchants?
Klarna runs its own process, and Klarna decides.
AnswerHow do you prevent disputes on Stripe?
Stop the fraud you can before the charge, and the confusion after it.
AnswerDoes Stripe Radar stop chargebacks?
Partly. Radar screens Stripe payment attempts for fraud in real time, so it can block stolen-card payments before they turn into fraud disputes.
Prevention and protection
What is chargeback protection, and is it the same as insurance?
It's a loose term for four different things.
AnswerWhat is chargeback mitigation?
Chargeback mitigation is everything a merchant does to cut what disputes cost.
AnswerHow do you prevent chargebacks on Shopify?
Use what Shopify already gives you, then close the gaps.
AnswerWhat causes chargebacks for ecom stores?
Most ecom chargebacks come from three places: stolen-card fraud, confusion or regret over a real purchase, and service failures.
AnswerIs a chargeback app worth it for a small store?
It depends on how many disputes you get and what your time is worth.
AnswerShould you hire a chargeback company or use chargeback software?
Hire a company when you want disputes handled for you and your volume justifies its fees; use software to stay in control and keep what you win.
AnswerWhich Shopify chargeback apps have no success fee?
Several, priced two ways. Flat subscriptions include Verdikx (from $29 a month) and ChargePay (from $19.99 a month on its Shopify listing), while Chargeblast and Chargeback.io charge per alert with no monthly fee.
Stop the next chargeback before it starts.
Install on Shopify in minutes, or sign up by card on any other platform, then connect your processors, helpdesk and carriers. Free 7-day trial on every plan.